Keavney & Streger

EMS Ambulance Healthcare Attorneys Law Firm

EMS and Healthcare Law Firm

  • Home
  • About Us
    • Margaret A. Keavney
    • Matthew R. Streger
  • Services
    • Client Types
      • Volunteer EMS Agency
      • Combination Volunteer/Paid EMS Agency
      • Municipal EMS Department
      • Private Ambulance/EMS Company
      • Hospital-Based EMS
      • Municipal Government
      • Healthcare Providers
      • Other Healthcare Entity
    • Practice Areas
    • Monthly General Counsel
    • CMS Cost-Data Collection
  • Speaking Events
  • Resources
    • New Jersey EMS Historical Documents
    • New Jersey EMS Data Collection Law
    • Public Resources
      • Videos
  • Non-Legal Services
  • EMS Dashboard Confessional
    • About the EMS Dashboard Confessional
    • EMS Dashboard Confessional Submission
  • Contact

EMS Dashboard Confessional, May 2019

May 6, 2019 by Matthew Streger

This month’s EMS Dashboard Confessional was submitted anonymously, with no other information:

“The mistake I made was believing that by allowing employees to have a say in decision-making, through surveys and voting, that I would achieve acceptance of decisions and “peace in the valley.” What I learned was that, no matter the decision, those who don’t get exactly what they want will feel no obligation to accept the wishes of others, and the fact that “the boss” went along with the majority opinion buys the boss nothing. Lesson learned!”

“Leadership is multi-faceted,” says Raphael Barishansky. “We have to look at this issue in the context of the greater relationship between management and employees. It’s important to ensure that all voices are heard, but this is not the only way that we obtain buy-in from staff.”

Michelle Kobayashi agrees. “Buy-in is more than offering ‘fair’ methods like surveys and voting.  Team members buy in when they trust their leaders and the decisions that are being made.  One way to build this trust is to take the time to speak to team members one-on-one and listen to what they have to say.  Even if there’s only time to meet with informal leaders, they’re the ones that have their finger on the pulse and will either support the decision or stand in its way.”

Michelle and Ray are completely on-point here. I often recommend Simon Sinek’s book ’Start With Why’ because of how important it is to explain why we are doing things to obtain collective support. I also want to know if this leader set the lane markers for the surveys and voting, to make sure that the majority made decisions that were keeping with the organization’s goals and values? What were the topics being decided by the committee? Were these topics that were appropriately delegated to a committee, or should those decisions have been made more collaboratively?

The greater question remains about what else did he or she do outside surveys and voting to obtain support from the greater group. Relying on simple majority rule will always leave the minority feeling disenfranchised, so that can never be the only answer to establishing a shared organizational commitment. Good managers are consistent, competent, and have integrity. Leaders have a vision, and communicate that vision to the group.

Filed Under: EMS Dashboard Confessional

Interested in Submitting Your Own EMS Dashboard Confessional?

If you would like to submit your own anonymous EMS Dashboard Confessional and help with the ongoing education of people in the EMS field, please find the submission form by clicking here.

Disclaimer: Attorney Advertising. The legal information presented on this website should not be construed to be formal legal advice, nor the formation of a lawyer or attorney client relationship. The information provided should not create an unjustified expectation that results can be obtained without regard to the specific factual and legal circumstances of your case.


© Copyright 2023 Keavney & Streger, LLC · All Rights Reserved